Knowledge

Home/Knowledge/Details

The comparison of aluminum alloy, zinc alloy, magnesium alloy and titanium alloy

As people's quality of life improves, the demand for aesthetic appeal and quality in products continues to rise. An increasing number of consumer products are being made using alloy materials. Metal materials convey a sense of high-end, sturdiness, and durability, while traditional plastic casing products are gradually being associated with the labels "cheap" and "low-quality" in the minds of consumers.

For consumer products, commonly used alloy materials include aluminum alloy, zinc alloy, and magnesium alloy. Titanium alloy, due to its good biocompatibility, is often used in the medical field. Below, I will introduce the characteristics of these several alloy materials and make a comparison.

introduction

Aluminum Alloy

 

The density of aluminum alloy ranges from 2.63 to 2.85g/cm³. It exhibits higher strength, good castability, plasticity, excellent electrical and thermal conductivity, good corrosion resistance, and weldability.

AL
Zn

Zinc Alloy

 

Zinc alloy has a low melting point, good fluidity, and is easily weldable. According to the manufacturing process, it can be classified into cast zinc alloy and wrought zinc alloy. Zinc alloy exhibits excellent malleability and ductility, mainly used for battery casings, printing plates, and daily hardware. The density of zinc alloy ranges from 6.3 to 6.7g/cm³, with a low melting point at 385℃, making it easily castable.

Magnesium Alloy

 

Magnesium alloy is an alloy primarily composed of magnesium along with other added elements. Due to its excellent casting, extrusion, cutting, and bending properties, magnesium alloys find extensive applications in automotive, electronics, textiles, construction, and military fields. With a melting point of 650°C, magnesium alloy has a lower melting point compared to aluminum alloy, offering good performance in die-casting processes. The specific strength of high-strength magnesium alloys can even rival that of titanium.

Mg
 
Ti

Titanium alloy

 

Titanium alloy refers to various alloys made by combining titanium with other metals. It exhibits high strength, excellent corrosion resistance, and high heat resistance. Titanium alloys are widely used in manufacturing components for aircraft engine compressors, frameworks, fasteners, landing gear, and more.

The density of titanium alloy is generally around 4.51g/cm³, which is only about 60% of steel's density. Consequently, the specific strength of titanium alloys is significantly higher than that of other metallic structural materials, allowing for the production of components that are both strong per unit and lightweight, with excellent rigidity.

 
comparison

 

Comparison Table of Physical Properties

Among these four alloys, titanium alloy is the hardest and also exhibits the highest strength. In terms of hardness, titanium alloy is significantly harder than the other three alloys. Concerning tensile strength, titanium alloy surpasses zinc alloy, followed by magnesium alloy, while aluminum alloy has the lowest strength.

 

Comparison between Strength and Hardness

However, in product structural design, weight also needs to be considered. When considering density, zinc alloy, having the highest density, actually has the lowest strength-to-weight ratio. Titanium alloy and magnesium alloy demonstrate higher strength, yet titanium alloy is expensive and has poor workability. Therefore, in components where weight and strength need comprehensive consideration, magnesium alloy is often preferred.